Extra Space Storage - 7569 - Bay Shore - 5th Ave

1775 5th Avenue , Bay Shore , NY 11706 (877) 449-1281
Book Now

We are experiencing high demand in this area.
Make sure you reserve a unit for free today to hold a storage space.

  • 3' x 5'

    3' x 5' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $29.00

    Regular Price

    $30.00
  • 5' x 5'

    5' x 5' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $37.00

    Regular Price

    $39.00
  • 5' x 5'

    5' x 5' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $42.00

    Regular Price

    $44.00
  • 5' x 8'

    5' x 8' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $56.00

    Regular Price

    $59.00
  • 5' x 10'

    5' x 10' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Flash Sale

    Discount Price

    $52.00

    Regular Price

    $55.00
  • 5' x 10'

    5' x 10' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $68.00

    Regular Price

    $72.00
  • 8' x 8'

    8' x 8' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $79.00

    Regular Price

    $83.00
  • 7' x 10'

    7' x 10' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $87.00

    Regular Price

    $92.00
  • 8' x 10'

    8' x 10' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $92.00

    Regular Price

    $98.00
  • 10' x 10'

    10' x 10' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $109.00

    Regular Price

    $115.00
  • 10' x 10'

    10' x 10' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $120.00

    Regular Price

    $127.00
  • 7' x 20'

    7' x 20' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $158.00

    Regular Price

    $168.00
  • 10' x 15'

    10' x 15' Unit

    Climate Controlled, Interior, Upstairs (Access via Elevator)

    Discount Price

    $150.00

    Regular Price

    $159.00
  • 10' x 15'

    10' x 15' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $165.00

    Regular Price

    $175.00
  • 10' x 20' Parking Space

    Drive Up Access, Household and Vehicle Storage Allowed

    Discount Price

    $122.00

    Regular Price

    $130.00
  • 10' x 20'

    10' x 20' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $228.00

    Regular Price

    $242.00
  • 10' x 25'

    10' x 25' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Flash Sale

    Discount Price

    $250.00

    Regular Price

    $265.00
  • 10' x 30'

    10' x 30' Unit

    1st Floor, Climate Controlled, Interior

    Discount Price

    $332.00

    Regular Price

    $346.00

How it works

Reserve 1

Reserve your
storage unit for free

Facility 2

Visit the facility to finalize the rental

Move 3

Move-in!

Operating Hours

Office

Sun closed
Mon 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Tue 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Wed 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Thu 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Fri 9:30 am - 6:00 pm
Sat 9:00 am - 5:30 pm

Unit Access

Sun 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Mon 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Tue 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Wed 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Thu 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Fri 6:00 am - 10:00 pm
Sat 6:00 am - 10:00 pm

Features and Amenities

  • Video cameras on site
  • Vehicle requires insurance
  • Electronic gate access
  • Vehicle requires title
  • Moving supplies for sale
  • Manager lives on-site
  • English, Spanish speakers on staff
  • Rent due on same day each month per lease start
  • Auto-pay available
  • Vehicle must be running
  • Vehicle requires registration
  • Insurance required
  • Insurance available
  • Cash accepted
  • Checks accepted
  • Allow 18-wheeler dropoff
  • Has 18-wheeler alleys

Additional information

Customer Reviews

  • 5.0 of 5 stars

    Martin King

    October 18th, 2025

    Yes most definitely

    Very ez transaction effortless couldn't get any better

  • 5.0 of 5 stars

    Damian Fontaine

    November 30th, 2022

    Awesome space

    Awesome place.Highly recommended

  • 5.0 of 5 stars

    Sharyce

    October 15th, 2022

    Overall experience was great .

    Great customer service , easy access to my unit.

  • 5.0 of 5 stars

    Charles J.

    April 2nd, 2022

    My was very professional and courteous.

    My experince was very professional and the staff was courteous and knowledgeable.

Back To Top